Review by MACYS.COM 2020-11-16
I really like this smudge proof eye liner. It is very smooth to apply and does not cake on when applying. It isn’t super black in color since it is called In The Black. It held up wearing all day at work and was easy to remove with makeup remover. It didn’t smear or run during the day. I would definitely buy and recommend this eye liner because I like the pencils better than the liquids.
- Review by MACYS.COM2020-11-16It’s indeed smudgefree eyeliner pencil. I am on my third day using this eyeliner and I am really liking it. It glides like butter, smooth, rich and easy to apply. Does not smear or smudge and transfers all day. Matte black ... makes my lash line looks full and thick. It did not irritate/ reddened my eyes when applied on waterline. Just little residue left one day when my eyes were watery from allergy. My first time using Lord & Berry and i am not disappointed.
- Review by MACYS.COM2020-11-16I put eye liner on 5 hours ago and it never smudge and Still looks great. Let never last long on me. It was real easy to put on too and pencil is soft to the skin. I would definitely buy this product.
- Review by MACYS.COM2020-11-16I was not familiar with this brand but thought I'd give it a try. I was not disappointed. The fine tip pencil made it easy to apply evenly over the eyelid and top and bottom water lines. By the end of the day color was still sharp and there were no smudges! What more can you ask for? I would definately recommend it.
- Review by MACYS.COM2020-11-16Eyeliner does not smudge and stays on all day. Very easy to apply a "cat eye"
- Review by MACYS.COM2020-11-16This eyeliner is creamy, easy to apply and looks fabulous. Stays on all day with no smearing and comes off easily at the end of the day. Sharpens perfectly.
- Review by MACYS.COM2020-11-16I really liked the ease with which this eyeliner applied. It glided effortlessly across my eyes in one smooth motion and never clumped up or appeared too thick in any one area. The line is evenly distributed and I’m left with a bold, dark eyeliner, which I am a fan of. The only flaw I would say exists is that this eyeliner is not entirely waterproof or smudge proof. For the most part, this liner stays put for hours on end, but if you accidentally rub your eyes be prepared for the liner to smudge. It also smudges pretty easily when it is wet, but it doesn’t come off unless you rub it while it’s wet. Overall I am happy with this liner because I like how easily and smoothly it applies, and that it lasts for hours without fading, but I do need to be conscientious about touching my eyes when wearing it so as not to smudge it.
- Review by MACYS.COM2020-11-16Very creamy formula and went on effortlessly. However as a smudge proof, waterproof formula it failed the test. After light exercise my liner wing Had disappear and under eye makeup became raccoon like. Very hard to remove, I was washing it off for days. Great purchase if only used as an upper eye liner for day wear/waterproof and exercising. Any additional areas will smudge off or become raccoons eyes
- Review by MACYS.COM2020-11-16This is a great eyeliner! I was so impressed with the vivid color, it is blackest black. It was easy to apply, especially on my lower eye, and it makes such a contrast! I wore it all night and it stayed put, no smears or smudges. This will be my new go-to eyeliner!
- Review by MACYS.COM2020-11-16This eyeliner goes on very smooth and does not smear. Lasts for the day and I would highly recommend.
- Review by Ve2017-02-17Great product
- Review by MACYS.COM